I  think it is Betsy Ross because there was a five pointed star in a safe since 1776 that’s a long time. Also she was a seamstress you don’t want a unprofessional  person to make the flag do you?  Also they shared a church it would have been easy to ask her.

                                               She reportedly rode to alert militia force in town 

                                                            April 16,1777 the age of sixteen    

                                                            Approach of the british regular    

                                                                By Ludington’s descendants

                                                                    Sybil Ludington 

                                                                     By local historian

                                                                  By william,Paul, and Jack

                                                       Of putnam County, New York and Danbury  

                                             The ride was similar to those performed by Paul